Passed Challanges with the FTMO/Prop Firm Robots

[Anonymous]

Hey Traders,

I’m happy to share with you that I passed 2 Prop Firm challenges with the FTMO Robot in the last 2 weeks!

In the first challenge, I used the Top Performer from the 7 FTMO Robots. Once I reached 2%, I increased the entry lots to 3. You can see the statistics for all trades in the account.

I used the Top 3 EAs in the second challenge without changing the lot size. Have a look at the statistics from the account.

The second account is with time limit so the target is 8%. Surprisingly the Prop Firm marked it as Passed at 7.99%! :)

I also recorded a video about it, and it will be published tomorrow – Friday the 26th of October.

Cheers,

[Anonymous]

Wow congratulations! Can I ask you about the time settings of the bots? 1-23 by default? Or did you modify them?

[Anonymous]

Yes, I use the default settings. I did not change anything.

[Anonymous]

Leverage 1:30, meaning you opted for FTMO Swing accounts?

[Anonymous]

Great job! I was running the GBPCAD also and it was losing multiple trades, so I shut it down. I’m using the V4.3 on 1M

I would love to get it working like yours. Any help is greatly appreciated.

 

[Anonymous]

[Anonymous]

Hi Jason,

The EAs will go through periods of profit and periods of losses.  You have to give the EAs more time to work.

Alan,

[Anonymous]

ok, Ill try it again

Thanks

[Anonymous]

If you check the trades in the reports, you will see that I traded the GBPCAD at the beginning of the week. At the end of the week, the AUDNZD was the profitable one.

So you need to track the 7 EAs and see which is the best one at any moment.

[Anonymous]

Glad to hear there was profitability on your side this week, unfortunately I have only radio silence with these EA’s for some reason. I’d love to rectify that.

[Anonymous]

I have a few of ideas.  1.  In the EA properties box reduce all four of the first four lines from 1.0 to 0.01 to see if you now start to get trades.  2.  Start a 200K FTMO demo swing trade account and add all 7 EAs.  I know the EAs will work there.  This way you can start tracking which EAs are performing the best in the current market environment while you continue to resolve the issues with the other brokers.  3.  Contact each broker and make sure they allow EAs.  4.  Give me access to your computer so I can make sure everything is setup properly.

Alan,

[Anonymous]

Hello Alan, I had already tried 0.01 lot size on one of the other accounts I was tracking, but still there were no entries.

The 3 brokers I have tried definitely allow EA’s because I use them regularly to trade many different EA’s on all my accounts, (demo & live).

Always I have other EA’s along side Petkos FTMO bot, (to verify MT4 functionality) and they trigger entries as normal.

For example this last week on the same account, I put an EA trading XAU/USD along with it, and as you can see that one made many entries;

Im not sure what else I can try, last week I deleted all my other MT4 terminals except this current EightCap one, to make sure there was no issues with conflicting terminals.

This next trading week I will reinstall the separate terminals again with different brokers and test them with smaller lot sizes only.

Very confusing why it doesn’t work for me.

 

 

[Anonymous]

Re: suggestion 4.

If someone can email me through EA Trading Academy, I can give you temporary access to my VPS where you can asess the situation.

[Anonymous]

Dear Petko,

Before I ask my question, I want to thank you. In demo mode, the 7 EA’s have performed so well since October 11 that is up 12.5%. That is 17 days.

Before I start the FTMO evaluation, I have a question.

Once I ran all 7 bots, how many days going backwards do I use to identify the top performer? 2 days, 1 week, 2 weeks?

My biggest fear is for the currency pair to start having a red streak after 12 trades with an 80-90% win rate. Any light you could shed on this would be of great help as I know you have come across this concern in the past.

Thank you Petko.

Ling

[Anonymous]

I would wait 1 week to identify the top performer.  You can change the amount of time to see what works best for you.

There will always be periods of profits and periods of losses.  There are many strategies that can be used to minimize losses so that over the long term the account will be profitable.  One strategy is to have several Expert Advisors trading.  When one EA is going through a period of drawdown the other EAs may be going through periods of profits.   Another strategy is to have a demo account of the 7 EAs and only move the Top performer to a live account or maybe the top 3 performers.  Then once each week (you can change this time to see what works best for you) review the demo account and move the top performers to the live account.

Hope this helps!

Alan,

[Anonymous]

Thank you Alan, much appreciated!

Ling

[Anonymous]

I just purchased the bot.
Is the 30 TF the best one to use?
Well done on passing the challenges.
My intention is to start low, $10k on the Funded Trader perhaps, and work my way up.

Thanks.

[Anonymous]

The FTMO Expert Advisors are to be placed on the M1 time frame.

Alan,

[Anonymous]

Thanks Alan.

I am running a test right now.
I intend to try various demos from 10k up to 200k.

 

[Anonymous]

Gonna start the challenge on a 25K Swing account tomorrow! I’m excited

[Anonymous]

Good luck!!
I have started testing on a 200k demo account (Alpha Capital Group). So far, hardly any draw-down and 3k up.
Day one.
Impressive.

I will give it a week and then test on a 1ok account and may go for a 10k funded account with The Funded Trader.
Slow and steady wins the race.

[Anonymous]

Thank you! Good luck to you too!!

Meanwhile, you can check how it’s going here: https://www.myfxbook.com/members/0xBitpool/ftmo-challenge-25k-top-3/10505789

[Anonymous]

Looking good!  Can you share your setting? I was looking at your trades and they are taking trades differently than mine.

Thanks for your time.

[Anonymous]

So for FTMO, 25K on a swing account, here are my settings (example for EURUSD)

[Anonymous]

hi,
just checked your stats, around $400 profit since last october? not the best results so far.

[Anonymous]

Hi Petko/Alan

I purchased the FTMO robots a month ago and  it passed the FTMO 50k DEMO challenge with all 7 EAs. Now I am enrolled in 100k real challenge and in last 12 days, it is up by 1.1 %. I still have my demo accounts to monitor which are the top EAs in last one week and based on that I am using top 3 EAs GBPCAD, EURUSD and AUDNZD in my real FTMO challenge:

My questions:

1) In 100k challenge, I am trading 3 pairs with 1 lot size , it that okay or should I change any settings/lot size? I am trading EA as is.

2)If I manually close any trade or manually open any trade, does it affect the EA settings or how EA trade?

3) Sometimes I see trade reverse and I tend to manually change it, should I do it or leave the EA as is? Of course that going in contrast of automatic trading. In long term, I want to trust the EA and trade automatically.

4) How to calculate the % of account size with lot size? How much account size I am risking per lot?

thanks,

Parveen

[Anonymous]

Answer 1)  Trading 3 pairs with 1 lot for each pair yields an account risk of 2%.   This is OK.

Answer 2)  Manually closing a trade does not affect the EA.  It will continue to function normally.

Answer 3)  If you are going to trade with EA’s then you need to have faith in them and not be changing their parameters or manually close the trades.  Having said that I will manually close a trade if it is close to the TP and I see it is starting to reverse directions.  This is the only time I will close a trade.

Answer 4)  Use a calculator to set lot size, etc.  https://www.babypips.com/tools/position-size-calculator

Alan,

 

 

[Anonymous]

Is there anything that I need to do before attaching  the FTMO bot on to its required pairs in MT5?
I noted that Alan said to download previous data prior to attaching? I think I have done this correctly.

Any additional advice would be great.

Thanks.

[Anonymous]

Hi PrimalSci,

Good luck with your challenge, and just be aware of your risk!  Keep us posted as to how it goes.

Alan,

[Anonymous]

Hey,

What do you mean by previous data? I have not heard about it and I am curious

 

Thanks

[Anonymous]

Thanks Alan.

Not going so good at the moment unfortunately but it is early days and need to give it a chance. Trading is difficult and will always fluctuate up and down. It is what it is.

Is the bot purely a plug and play bot?

Thank you.

 

[Anonymous]

Hi PrimalSci,

The only thing you need to change would be the first four lines in the EA Properties box based upon your account size.

The following is the recommended lot sizes based upon a 10K account which limits risk to 1%:

Amount for a new position = 0.3 lots
Maximum position amount = 0.3 lots
Amount to add on addition = 0.3 lots
Amount to close on reduction = 0.3 lots

* For larger accounts simply scale the lot sizes.

Alan,

 

[Anonymous]

Superstar.
Thanks Alan!!

Will keep you updated on how it goes!

[Anonymous]

Hey, I just wanted to start my first ftmo challenge with this bot. I have 2 questions:
1. I live in germany, with eur as currency. Do I have to choose EUR or USD as currency when I want to start ftmo?
2. I have to take the swing account, Right?

Thanks Guys!

[Anonymous]

Hi Rick,

Answer 1)  It is up to you as to whether you should choose EUR or USD.  However, since you are in Germany EUR might be your better choice.

Answer 2)  Yes, use the swing account!

Alan,

[Anonymous]

In my opinion both of your strategies is dangerous. The scale up one is dangerous if you don’t monitor it all the time if consecutive loss happened, it will violate 5% daily limit. The three top performers EA will be dangerous too, your DD is close to 5%, and it’s just lucky not violate it.

[Anonymous]

Hey Joko,

I appreciate your feedback!

True, but one should not use the scaling-up method if one can’t monitor the trades. I decided to use the scaling-up system only when I am around the monitor.

About the second one, it depends on your risk tolerance. It’s not luck. I’ve done plenty of tests with the EAs and the lot size to calculate that the chances of passing the challenge and not violating the rules are huge. If that ”risk” is too much for one one, it’s just a matter of lowering the lots.

[Anonymous]

Hello!

Thank you for all that you guys do.

I have 3 questions.

1. If I am closely following EURUSD and have decided to use it for an evaluation, how do you decide when is the best moment to begin using the scaling plan? After seeing 1, 2 or 3 red trades or is it based on a different criteria?

2. I would like to ask if soon there will be a way to create a script to automatically trade with the same number of lots if the current trade is a loser, but if the current trade is a winner, to automatically add “X” number of lots before placing the next trade.

3. I am considering purchasing the TOP 10 Forex robots and would like to confirm if they are all a 1:2 loss/win ratio to use the scaling plan to pass a challenge.

Thank you,

Ling

[Anonymous]

answer 1:  This is explained in the cheat sheet you can download from the FTMO course,  However, I will explain how I would use the scaling plan for a 10K account.  When I would start the challenge I would start with a lot size of 9.3 lots.  Once I have $300 profit I would increase the lot size to 0.9 so that the next time the EA entered a trade it would trade with a lot size of 0.9 lots.  Then once the account reached a profit of $900 I could increase the lot size to 2.7 lots.  The idea about how much to scale up is so that if the EA hit the SL the account would be reduced to would not exceed the daily amount of 5%.

answer 2:   This IS done by how you set up the first 4 lines in the FTMO EA properties.

answer 3:    The TOP 10 Forex robots do not adhere to the 1:2 loss/win ratio.

Alan,

[Anonymous]

Thank you Alan, your answers are very helpful and much appreciated.

Ling

[Anonymous]

Dear Petko,

In one of your account you use Forexpropfirm and its leverage is 1:30. In your opinion for the one shoot/entry not martingle, is it always enough?

[Anonymous]

Hi joko,

Leverage of 1:30 is sufficient to pass the FTMO challenge.

Alan,

[Anonymous]

The FTMO Robot has passed another challenge! This time it was the Infinity Forex Funds 50k account.

I used all the robots trading simultaneously with 1% (normal) risk per trade. Once the account reached 5% profit, I doubled the entry lot (keeping it at 5% max Daily Loss). This is a variation of the scaling-up system I teach in the FTMO Course.

Once the equity reached $55,050, the trades were closed automatically using the integrated target protection settings in V5.1.

It took about 30 days for the FTMO Robots to pass the challenge. EURAUD and GOLD were the most profitable pairs. You can have a look at all of the stats here.

At the beginning of the challenge, I had the FTMO Robots V5.0, and then I replaced them with the Robots from V5.1 (that is why there are double magic numbers). I also doubled the lots according to the V5.1 values.

Scaling up works great for me! And I don’t find it as risky as the Martingale approach because we reinvest the profits in the account.

We plan to integrate the scaling-up method in the inputs of the EAs so that when one wants to double (any multiplier), the lots can do that automatically at a certain point.

In this example, it was just one one-time manual intervention but it would have been great to set this from the beginning:

– increase 2 x lots once the account reaches $52500 (5%).

We will work on that, and as soon as we develop it, we will add it as an option in the EAs.

[Anonymous]

Nice!  I will start a 50K Evaluation using v5.1 robots.

Alan,

[Anonymous]

I’ve passed FTMO with earlier version but I adjusted the strategy slightly so it worked for me. Using latest version on my 2 funded accounts now and it’s doing well

[Anonymous]

Dear Fellow Traders,

I’m genuinely thrilled to share a major milestone in my trading journey – the FTMO Robot has successfully navigated and conquered my 1 Phase 15k Challenge! 🎉

I initially kicked off with V5.0, diligently trading for a month with the Top 3 performers. However, in the pursuit of optimizing results, I decided to make a strategic move. I upgraded to V5.1, tweaking the lot size to be twice the default for the top performer, USDCHF. The outcome? It delivered the maximum profit during this trading.

I used V5.0 initially but it was cost to cost even after 1-month trading with Top 3 performer later I replaced all the robots with V5.1 with Top 3 performers but this time 2x the lot size of default for the top 1 performer ( USDCHF). It gave me the maximum profit in the meantime.

The journey took me a solid 34 calendar days, during which USDCHF and EURAUD emerged as the most profitable pairs for me.

For those keen on the nitty-gritty details and statistics, feel free to check out the comprehensive breakdown on my FX Blue profile:- https://www.fxblue.com/users/480135

Happy and genuine trading vibes to all!

[Anonymous]

So did you just keep using the same top 3 performers from your test time? I have been trialling the 8 bots as suggested for to see what are top performers

[Anonymous]

Hello Allan,

Thanks for this.

Sorry if you’ve already answered this but just to double check that your original post in this thread refers to the performance of the  FTMO EA straight out of the box with the original settings and no modifications? This was a month ago so is there an update on the performance since then? I ask because I see some people on other threads complaining of slow activity.

[Anonymous]

Hi David,

Sorry, I am not sure what original post you are referring too. Anyway, being in the United States I can no longer trade the FTMO robots on the FTMO challenge as it is not allowed by FTMO. What I can tell you is when I was trading the FTMO robots on an FTMO challenge they were not modified!

Alan,

[Anonymous]

Hi there,

Is there anything in particular we need to watch out for when purchasing a challenge from a prop firm. Here is an example from a prop firm EA limitations.

Yes, we allow the use of any risk management EA or Trading Bot as long as they are not used in the following ways:
Martingale
Tick scalping
Reverse arbitrage trading
Latency arbitrage trading
Hedge arbitrage trading
HFT (High Frequency Trading), Grid Trading

So would the FTMO Robot be allowed in the above case ? Not sure how the EA FTMO robot functions to be sure on what to look out for.

thanks in advance

Patrick

 

 

[Anonymous]

Hi Patrick,

Yes you can use the FTMO robots as they do not trade under any of the conditions you noted above.

Alan,

[Anonymous]

Hello Traders!

We have taken the next step in our transparency efforts with our students by making the results from our challenges public:

On the new page, you will find all the accounts we trade – challenges and funded accounts!

You can track how the Robots are performing at any given moment with live records! This page aims to test all the robots for you, so you can easily decide which ones you want to trade!

Note: Please do not consider any information on that page as financial advice! Choosing which robot to trade with on which prop firm is a personal decision!

Cheers,

Petko A

PS: We have also changed the name of the FTMO robot app to Prop Firms Robot because we don’t want to be associated with FTMO or any other Prop Firm.

[Anonymous]

Hello traders,

I’ve got really good news to share!

The Prop Firm Robots (or FTMO ROBOT) have successfully passed yet another challenge! This time, it was on a $100k challenge account with Infinity Forex Funds. I relied on the Top 5 EAs from the Prop Firms App on the weekly timeframe. I took a bit of a risk by doubling the lots once the account hit 5%. It took the Prop EAs a solid 40 days to pass the challenge, and what’s even more impressive is that they managed to gain a whopping 15% in just the last 30 days, which is awesome to see!

Here is an image of some of the stats:

Kind Regards,
Nikos

[Anonymous]

Wow, thanks for posting Nikos that’s really encouraging. I’m new to this and I just purchased those bots last night. Just waiting to receive them now.

[Anonymous]

Hey Pete,

Thank you very much and of course if you have any questions, let me know and I will assist you!!

Thank you!

Kind Regards,
Nikos

[Anonymous]

Hi Nikos,

You’re welcome! Thanks so much and yeah, I’ll definitely hit you up for any advice moving forward. Nice to have a ‘big brother’ out there who’s already been ‘through the trenches’.

I wish you success and happy trading,

Pete

[Anonymous]

Hey Pete,

Thank you so much and I wish you happy trading and success as well!

As mentioned, I am here whenever you have a question, just let me know!

Kind Regards,
Nikos

[Anonymous]

Hello traders,

Here is the video about this challenge. I hope it will be useful to you to know how exactly I passed the challenge with the Prop Firm Robots:

[Anonymous]

Just to clarify, did you check the top weekly performers every day? and adjust the loaded Robots based on this?

[Anonymous]

Good question because I loaded up the XAUUSD M5 bot and by the time it entered a trade I see now that it’s not even on the list and drawing down now.

Seems we have to be pretty vigilant with it. Should be look at the weekly and only seek out the monthly for confirmation or?

[Anonymous]

Do we need to allow for the indicators to show on screen for the EA to take trades or this is not affecting trading?

I have added 3 top performers from the app for the last 2 days have not opened any trades yet. Please advise.

[Anonymous]

Good day EA Trading academy members

Been a great couple of days with the FTMO Robot’s…

Trusting that it will continue.

Anyone else been making some good profits.
I have setup a nice portfolio and I am hoping it will pay off.
I will leave the robots to run now and see what happens.

[Anonymous]

Dear traders,

We are really happy to announce that we passed a 100k challenge with Infinity Forex Funds using the Top 3 Robots from the Prop Firm Robots App on the weekly timeframe!

It took about 2 weeks for the EAs to pass the challenge and today was the day that it was passed!

You can also see here the results:

As you can see it is the first on the list and they passed with 10.05% profit gain!

You can access this table from this link below:

Best FTMO & Prop Firm Robots

Kind Regards,
Nikos

[Anonymous]

Hi Nikos,

How did you go about choosing the EAs to use to pass this challenge? Did you choose the top three EAs from the previous week going into a new week or did you change the EAs every day based on what was top 3 at the time?

Many thanks,

George.

[Anonymous]

Hey George,

I was checking every day to see if there is any EA that is more profitable than the ones I was already trading with!

Kind Regards,
Nikos

[Anonymous]

I see, so, would you check at the end of each day for the following morning or at the beginning of the day ready for the day?

Many thanks!

George.

[Anonymous]

Hey George,

I am sorry for the late reply.

I look at every start of the day to see if there is any more profitable robot.

Kind Regards,
Nikos

[Anonymous]

@Nikos I think what would be beneficial to all is setting a daily routine and checklist for us if possible?

For example:

1. Do you check the top 3 each morning, evening etc
2. Do you close positions for weekends?
3. If an EA has dropped off the top 3 but has an open position do you leave it or close it?
4. Are there any conditions that require manual intervention such as closing all for NFP/CPI/FOMC?

Thanks

Craig

 

 

[Anonymous]

Hey Craig,

I am sorry for the late reply.

So, these are the answers to your questions:

1. I check every start of the day or morning for more profitable robots
2. I do not close the positions
3. I close the position if I have to change the robot
4. I believe that before the news, the robots close the trades automatically but in case it does not happen you can close them manually

Hope this helps!

Kind Regards,
Nikos

[Anonymous]

Thanks Nikos! I like to have a structure to work to. By doing it this way it fits nicely to my trading routine. Will see how the demo goes next few weeks

 

Craig

 

[Anonymous]

Hey Craig,

It’s always good to have a structure and sure let me know how it goes!

Kind Regards,
Nikos

[Anonymous]

how long before the news should I close the trade?

[Anonymous]

If it does not work automatically, it’s good to turn it off about 15-30 minutes before the news!

Kind Regards,
Nikos

[Anonymous]

EJ and UJ weekly EAs for 50k 1%, closed after 24 hours with total profit 850$ hitting a manually moved SL, close to hitting TP but price reversed. Yesterday, UJ and UCHF weekly closed hitting SL at 677$ total loss. Replaced the UCHF with EJ. Working on demo, if EJ and UJ repeat the wins 2-3 times more I ll try them on one of my challenges.

[Anonymous]

So Far so good, this is the best attempt I have had to date. Up 5.8% using 1% Risk and setting the Top 3 Weekly EA’s every morning. BTC took a chunk but paid it back the next day. Only Issue I have is the contract sizing on XAG, I needed to up the lots by a factor of 10 on RoboForex

[Anonymous]

Hey Craig,

It’s great that you are having good results, thanks for sharing!

Kind Regards,
Nikos

[Anonymous]

Hey Craig, quick question: When you say you set them up every morning, do you mean that you turn them off and on again in the morning or do you download new weekly EA`S every day?

thank you!

[Anonymous]

Hi Andre,

 

I don’t turn them off and on, I just look at the app each morning and see what are the top three on the 1 Week setting.

I just make sure each day I have those top 3 running

[Anonymous]

Hi ive just seen the video on youtube and that you can download the top 3 for free. However i have logged in and it wont let me download them as it keeps saying im not logged in when i go to the page, any help on this?

[Anonymous]

Hello, the download link is available in the video description. For convenience I’m sending it here as well.

[Anonymous]

Hi All,

Hit 10% Target this morning. Will keep testing a few more weeks. Will start fresh again today. If I can keep this sort of consistency I will put on a real challenge

 

[Anonymous]

Little Update, After hitting 10% I have kept the process going.

It has had a bit of a flat spot and back to 10% gain but main thing for me is Daily DD not been touched and the balance has recovered. Lets see what the next week hold… roll on 20%

 

[Anonymous]

Hey Craig,

Thank you for sharing your results and we are happy to know that our robots are doing well!

Keep updating us with the performance and results!

Thank you!

Kind Regards,
Nikos

[Ron Lee]

Hi,
can check if using the top 5 weekly will get positive result ? cause after 1 weeks I still in the negative -2.5%  ?
Or should I switch to top 3 weekly instead?

[Anonymous]

I can’t say about the top 5 but the Top 3 Has been working for me, however last few weeks have been flat-ish (See Image) Hovering between 12,652 – 13,185

 

But this seems to be more to do with the market Phase as My other EA’s are underperforming too.

 

[Ron Lee]

should I change or stick to top 5 ?

[Anonymous]

Hello everyone on the forum. I am using the prop firm FXIFY. I started a $100k challenge with FTMO prop firm bots. So far, I am at -2.5%. I am using the 5 best bots on a monthly frame. After 2 weeks, I left 3 bots that were profitable. Is this approach correct? Is there any documentation with a description of how to use these bots? (I’ve already watched the video)

[Anonymous]

Hey Konrad,

Actually, the best approach is to first test on a demo and when you are comfortable enough, you can just go ahead and trade them on a challenge.

What we are basically doing also is that we check in the app to see if there is any more profitable robot than the ones we are trading currently. For example, let’s say that we have a USDJPY EA but on the first robots in the App, we see a different or one of the same pair but with different magic number, we just change the robot that is trading with the one that is on the top 3 or 5.

Hope this helps!

Let me know if you have any questions!

Kind Regards,
Nikos

[Ron Lee]

Hi can check for the infinity challenge I notice cannot use crypto so for the top 5 robot approach should I just ignore the crypto bot or I just include top 5 non crypto ea instead ?

[Anonymous]

Hey Ron,

Indeed Infinity does not offer crypto assets so you cannot set the crypto EAs. You just need to ignore it and just get the next one if it is a metals or forex pair.

Kind Regards,
Nikos

[Anonymous]

Sorry, can check the bot keep losing day by day, how should I handle it else I might lose the challenge, should I hold but when I will know when to resume the same approach ?

[Author]

Posts