Prop Firm Robot App Successes/Failures

[Lisa Johnson]

What is the app’s success and failure rates in the hands of its customers?

[Valentina Bolatto]

Hi Lisa, have you been able to pass the challenge with the app? I just bought the app as I had tries some eas Petko gave for free and the results were great, but those form the app are not performing as well and I have almost lost the account… coudl you share yoru experience? thanks

[Lisa Johnson]

Hi Valentina

I have not bought the Prop Firm App as yet and I only see the videos from Petko showing successful challenges. UI want to buy, but first I would like to see ordinary people with good results. I was looking in this blog, but could not find any.

 

[Valentina Bolatto]

Hi Lisa, there are some success in the other forum inside the app, but I think it is only for costumers.

 

[Sand0r]

Hi everyone,

I am happy to share my recent results. Some of them are on a good way, with others I wasn’t very happy (might be due to market conditions). I have the following accounts running:

1. Personal Roboforex Cent Account: I went in with top 5 Robots from the app with high risk – without taking a look into the charts – just trusting the top 5 from the last week :D Probably a classical newbe behaviour. The account went 10% down and i stopped it.

2. Personal Roboforex Cent Account: I did some research and went in with top 5 Robots from 1 week and 1 month with low risk. Everyhing went fine for 1 week, I did more than 2% profit. I raised the risk the week after and went down 4%. I adjusted the strategy the week after, taking top 3 from 5 years, 1 year and 1 month with the for me best looking charts (USDJPY M15 #1866099885, XAGUSD M15 #1376098563 and XAUUSD M15 #971234014). This broker doesn’t have crypto trading.

3. Personal BlackBull Account: I took the top 5 from 1 week and 1 moth without considering the charts (I started it the same time as 2.). I went down 2%. Now adjusting to the same strategy as my second account, taking the top 4 robots from 5 years, 1 year and 1 month with stable looking charts (USDJPY M15 #1866099885, XAGUSD M15 #1376098563 and XAUUSD M15 #971234014, ETHUSD M15 #2077851698). I am currently even with this account (+ – 0%).

4. FTMO 10k Account: Started with top 5 robots on weekly basis for the app. Everything went fine so far, with a bit ups and downs. I adjusted to the same strategy as 2./3, taking the top 4 robots from the past 5 years, 1 year and 1 moth. I will adjust it every 2-4 weeks. I changed the robots settings and changed slightly the start and stop signals for 1-2 pips to avoid “copy trading”. From time to time I close the trades manually (before hitting stop loss or take profit) for the same reason. Started 29.09.2024, Currently 1,3% in profit.

5. 5%ers 5k challenge. Started with top 5 robots on weekly basis for the app. Everything went fine so far, with a bit ups and downs. I adjusted to the same strategy as 2./3, taking the top 4 robots from the past 5 years, 1 year and 1 moth. I will adjust it every 2-4 weeks. I changed the robots settings and changed slightly the start and stop signals for 1-2 pips to avoid “copy trading”. From time to time I close the trades manually (before hitting stop loss or take profit) for the same reason. Started 22.09.2024, currently 4% in profit.

6. FundedNext 6k challenge: Started with top 5 robots on weekly basis for the app. Everything went fine so far, with a bit ups and downs. I adjusted to the same strategy as 2./3, taking the top 4 robots from the past 5 years, 1 year and 1 moth. I will adjust it every 2-4 weeks. I changed the robots settings and changed slightly the start and stop signals for 1-2 pips to avoid “copy trading”. From time to time I close the trades manually (before hitting stop loss or take profit) for the same reason. Started 06.10.2024, currently -0,1% in loss.

Hope this helps you to reach your goals as well! I will keep this post updated :)

[Valentina Bolatto]

Thank you SandOr. i Did not understand how you chose robot. the best one form 5 years, 1 year and 1 month?

At the moment I had amazing results in demo, but when i started using robots in challenges it was a disaster. I followed the strategy suggested by another user who had passed several challenges who changed the robot everyday with the best 4 daily robots. I lost a challenge in 1 week, I lost 1% in a founded account and about 3% in a Fundednxt 6K challenge. On thursday I stopped all robots. I will try with your strategy. thanks

 

 

[Sand0r]

Hi Valentina,

You are very welcome.

Just to bei transparent Here: I did not pass the challenges yet, I am still in an experimential mode :D

 

My strategy: Trading 3-5 of the top Bots with Low risk settings.

Further steps:

– Select filter that fits to your challenge and start with 5 years.

– Write down the Bots that have a stable Chart (going straight Up, with Not so many down or sideways trend) starting by the First one.

– select the 1 year Filter and Note down the top Bots as described before

– select the 1 month Filter and do the Same

– Now check, which Bots appear in 5 years, 1 year and One month and select the top 3-5.

-I think it’s Important to mention that especially the 1 month Filter ist very relevant (you could leave Out the First stept with 5 years, I Just wanted to be Sure to have Bots that are Short and Long term very good)

 

As mentioned I filtered the following bot:

USDJPY M15 #1866099885, XAGUSD M15 #1376098563 and XAUUSD M15 #971234014 and ETHUSD M15 #2077851698

 

Of course there is No guarantee that they will continue to perform good, but the chances are high :) and remember: there are ups and Downs, but at the end of a week or moth you should BE in profit

 

 

 

[Sand0r]

Hi everyone,

some update from my accounts:

 

1. Personal Roboforex Cent Account: Stopped (as described before).

2. Personal Roboforex Cent Account: The past week went well and I recovered some losses. Currently -3% in loss, but some floating profits. It will probably recover in the next weeks.

3. Personal BlackBull Account: Did some wrong config, went down -10%, got “fear” and stopped it :D

4. FTMO 10k Account: Currently 1,73% in profit, floating profits are waiting

5. 5%ers 5k challenge: Currently 5,6% in profit, floating profits are waiting

6. FundedNext 6k challenge: Currently 1% in profit, floating profits are waiting.

7. Personal Roboforex Demo Account (for testing bots): 10k with 2% in profit.

 

Hope this helps you to reach your goals as well! I will keep this post updated :)

 

[Orlando Stevenson]

See below

[Orlando Stevenson]

Hi, Everyone. I’m new to the Prop App. Testing is going very well this week on my demo accounts. I’m applying Petko’s daily top 3 methodology a few hours after the market opens, changing out MT4 EAs as needed, and closing any open trades if swapping out an EA..  all using high risk. Silver (XAGUSD) had a nice run today and is still in the top three.

[Ilan Vardy]

Hey Orlando,

Great to hear! While you’re testing on a demo account, try a few other methods. You may be surprised by the results :-)

 

Trade safe,

Ilan

[Vince]

Hi,

I have been using the application for about 1 month and every time I place a crypto robot on a chart it does not work, unlike forex robots. I’m on a FTMO account. Recent example: the BTC robot whose code ends in 443 has not opened any trade in the platform while on the application we see an open and winning trade very recently. What’s going on? Thanx

[Ilan Vardy]

Hi Vincent,

If you’re seeing the blue hat in the corner of the chart, the EA has attached successfully. If the EA didn’t place a trade when it was supposed to, this must be down to the broker or settings. I’d suggest running a backtest for the last week or 2 and see if it should/would have opened a trade on FTMO. If it does have a trade in the backtest, the problem lies with the broker not executing the trade.

Thanks,
Ilan

 

[Author]

Posts