- This topic has 36 replies, 12 voices, and was last updated 1 week, 5 days ago by
.
-
Posts
-
-
This space is dedicated to your ideas and suggestions for new features in Top 10 Robots App. Share your thoughts on what could enhance your trading experience, discuss potential improvements, and explore what others have proposed.
-
Hi there,
Congratulations on the launch of the Top 10 EAs app.
With that, I think the Portfolio EAs need a bit of love. Is there any chance we can have the News filter generated in the Portfolio EAs similar to the individual ones?
I also, think a summary Info Panel or Dashboard will be very helpful on the Portfolio EA, similar to the separately downloaded ones.
Cheers,
Tony
-
Hey Antoine,
I will forward this to our team!
Thank you for your suggestion!
Kind Regards,
Nikos -
Thank you Marin,
I have the following suggestions to improve the Top 10 EA App page:
-Would it be possible for the magic numbers of the individual EAs be coped to the portfolio mode? This will let us track the top performers weekly and compare against the dashboard best EAs. Currently when you export in portfolio mode it creates its own magic number making it hard to compared against the dashboard top performers.
-Add current position (Buy/Sell) and lot sizes for each EA for your virtual demo account. This would help us compare live accounts against your virtual Demo account from Blackbulls. Currently all I can compare is the most recent trade is a winner or loose. Seems to match pretty well with my live account, but having the current position would help and give confidence to the users that trades are similar. i.e its like having virtual MyFXBook
-Have the option to close trades on Friday night (Allow uses to select “close trades in profit” or “Close all” on Friday night
-
Hey there,
Sorry for the late reply.
Thank you for your suggestions, I will forward them to our team!
Kind Regards,
Nikos
-
-
Hi,
Apologies for this not being directly relevant to the prop firm robots app, but do you / would you offer a yearly access option to the top 10 EA app rather than lifetime access? Providing another price point with the yearly access being slightly cheaper as you do with the prop firm app?
Many thanks,
George. -
Hey George,
So, we do provide 1 year license for pairs of the Top 10 EAs App but you do not get all EAs, you get what pair you choose to purchase.
You can see more on what I mean here:
Hope this helps!
If you have any more questions, let me know!
Kind Regards,
Nikos -
hi Pekto and team
im new to trading and i have just completed your 21 day programme.
thank you so much, it was an overall good experience for me.
i would really love to have access to your to your Top 10 App, i think it can really help me to get started. im not too comfortable at this stage creating my own EAs.
unfortunately for me, the price is too high, i think i speak for most new traders.
so my question is, have you thought of maybe creating a monthly subscription model for us new traders who cannot afford the app upfront. this would allow us to start making money with it and eventually be able to buy the full package.
this will be another revenue stream for you, i guess, as many of us would depend on it until our trading skills are good.
just a thought for you to consider Pekto. it would really help.
Regards
Tsholo
-
Hey Tsholo,
We are really glad to know that you liked our 21 Day Algo Program.
About your suggestion, I will forward this to the team!
Kind Regards,
Nikos -
Thank you.
Looking forward to a positive response.
Regards,
Tsholo
-
Hey Tsholo,
Sure!
Kind Regards,
Nikos
-
-
I have a suggestion to add a news filter feature in the EA portfolio.
thank you
-
Hey Agus,
Thank you for the suggestion!
Kind Regards,
Nikos -
-
-
Hello,
I have now added the top 3 to a 100k challenge, unfortunately there is not really a positive result on the 3rd day, but let’s wait.
How often should you swap the EAs, daily or weekly?
How do I know that there is an update of the parameters, are the “comment” numbers changed or do they remain?-
Hey Andre,
What we are doing is that we swap the EAs daily as there are changes most of the time.
To see if there is an update, you need to check the magic number of each and cross check with what you have in the platform.
Hope this helps!
Let me know if you have any more questions!
Kind Regards,
Nikos
-
-
Halo,
I want to buy the top 10 eurusd, what I want to ask is if there is a problem for every day there is a change in EURUSD how can I get the EA change again and put the old EA into MT4 if the old one is still running, do I have to close it first then reinstall the EA new .
-
Hey Karim,
It’s best that you close any positions that the old robot has opened and then place the new EA on the chart!
Kind Regards,
Nikos -
-
-
-
Hello Petko,
I hope the EA can use a timeframe other than just M15. I would like the EA to be able to trade with the H1 timeframe.
-
Hey Agus,
At the moment, all of our robots are based on the M15 timeframe so they work on this timeframe only!
Kind Regards,
Nikos
-
-
-
Risk per trade in % would be a great addition!
If you were to put something like 1%, the lots would be calculated so that the most you would lose via SL would be 1% of the account.
Every pair and strategy will risk different amounts when setting the same standard starting lot, having a % Risk Per Trade would help with the calculations!
-
When choosing which Robots to add to the Portfolio, I would like a way to remove Robots from the Portfolio set that’s ready to download
Next to each Robot there is an Add feature, but also having a Remove feature would be very helpful
For example, if I add the Top 10 from the 5 Year, I can then go to the 1 Week view and click Remove on certain Robots that may not be performing well in that timeframe.
This would stop me from having to copy Magic Numbers, searching different timeframes to make sure they’re not there and do my own filtering, back and forth, before downloading a Portfolio set.
-
Hello, I saw that there are a few really good suggestions made by other users, is there any follow-up?
Especially this one bothers me as well (was made in May; a solution would enhance the user experience A LOT):
-Would it be possible for the magic numbers of the individual EAs be coped to the portfolio mode? This will let us track the top performers weekly and compare against the dashboard best EAs. Currently when you export in portfolio mode it creates its own magic number making it hard to compared against the dashboard top performers.Another request – would it be possible to add some other currency pairs like with AUDCAD, GBPAUD, USDCAD? This would make it possible to trade less correlated pairs like EURUSD and AUDCAD simultaneously for a even better portfolio diversification imho…
-
Hello @Marin (or any other admins of this forum, if there are any….) – why is there no response from your side at all to these requests? Can you please enlighten the community and me what are your further plans? Why do you not offer more FX pairs as I suggested, what improvements do you plan in the near future? As mentionned in another thread, I am still in my 30 days testing period, only with negative results so far, so if I have the impression that this Top 10 App project will not be improved in the future I really think I will use the 30 days money-back-guarantee, as I don’t see really any commitment from you, the developpers, currently… Sorry about my frustration, but I paid quite some money for the App and I really would like if this works…
-
Hi Alesamo,
You might want to take a look at my topic on using the Top10 app robots. It might be give you some ideas as to how to proceed with your trading journey.
Alan,
-
Hello Alan, thanks a lot for your reply, for sure I am following your posts, much appreciated. I am following a similar approach (testing various strategies regarding the Top 10 App), but currently all with negative results (as yours). That being said, I really want to hear from the sellers of this App – what do they think regarding the current negative results, what are their plans for the future, are there any amendmens/improvements planned etc. Unfortunately, in the latest videos on YouTube I only see Petko trying to sell useless EAs from FXAutomater for affiliate commissions, sorry to say, but that just is my impression…
-
Hi Alesamo,
Definately get the sellers comments. The Top 10 app robots are created using Blackbull historical data using ExpressGenerator and EA Studio. I also have these tools. I have proven to myself that when using brokers other than Blackbull not all the robots will perform as expected with some even being losers. To have success with these robots you should use the Blackbull broker. Other than that I have found it necessary to test for yourself using the broker you plan on using to determine which robots will provide profits. This is what I have to do as I am in the US and do not have access to the Blackbull broker.
Alan,
-
-
-
-
-
-
Maybe it’s just me, but I am struggling a bit with the pace new robots are added and are replacing robots that previously were – often for a long time – in the “Top 10″… Especially the latest addition of new time frames meant that robots that were in the top 10 often for weeks or months are now “worthless” (u know what I mean)…? A good feature would be a “Manage Only” function in the variables of an EA; when activated the EA should only manage currently open positions, but not open any new ones. At the moment it is recommended (at least as far as I understood) to just close open positions when a robot should be replaced, but very often these robots are in drawdown and therefore need to be closed with a loss… With the feature proposed the bot at least has a chance to close open positions in profit without the need to monitor it permanently….
-
-
Hello, me again… I finally decided to not use my “30 day money back guarantee”, because most probably it only would have been quite some wasted time to argue why the EAs weren’t profitable (although I can show you plenty of proof), and to be honest I still hope that I will get some value from money…. What’s really annoying me, however, is the negligence/ignorance of the owners/admins of this forum to be honest… Many people – and most of them paid quite a lot of money for the services of this site – make comments/make suggestions (sometimes even good ones), ask questions… but still Petko and his team seem to just give a sh**, because there is no reply, there is no answer, or maybe – if you are lucky – only many weeks later… I really don’t understand that… Why is it so difficult to say: “Well, XY, thank you for your suggestion, but for XXX we don’t think it’s possible to implement this feature” or “Well, YX, thanks for your interest, we just think your suggestion is really stupid, because….” or “Geez, thanks for your comment, but we don’t comment on any comment….” or something like that – I JUST DON’T GET IT!!!!
-
-
-
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.